
Not necessary a Fair comparison, because Bella was not a virgin, surely she didn't really have many actions in recently as far as we know, and she was cleary craving for it so when the time finnaly come she did hold back nothing.
Jill on the other hand was a total noob, her fate sealed in episode 7 the moment we found out she is virgin, despite this, the first sex scene was not entirely horrible, it served the purpose very well, the problem is everything els what came after.
But if we truly want to compare her to someone that should be the Original Virgin of the game Maya, She was the other and original " never been with a Guy before ", character, and everything with her, is much more genuine, more believable, and better. there is a proper progress with her, and one thing lead to an another and etc.
Jill on the other hand, basically repeated the same scene, but before that, dpc turned up the cringe level, with everything else